Sunday, July 24, 2011

Hacker Who Turned in Bradley Manning Is a Bigger Scumbag Than We Imagined OpEd

Hacker Who Turned in Bradley Manning Is a Bigger Scumbag Than We Imagined

by Adrian Chen, m.gawker.com
July 14th 2011 12:41 PM

Around a year after Bradley Manning was arrested for allegedly leaking to Wikileaks, Wired has finally published the full chat logs between the Army private and hacker Adrian Lamo, who turned him into authorities. Man, does Lamo come across as a scumbag.

If you remember: Manning reached out to Lamo on May 21, 2010 over encrypted chat. He proceeded to spill his guts, confessing to Lamo that he leaked more than 250,000 State Department cables as well as the "Collateral Murder" video, and another video of an Afghanistan airstrike to Wikileaks. Wired published heavily redacted chat bits of these conversations last June when it broke the story. But the rest were withheld, Wired explained, since Manning was "discussing personal matters that aren't clearly related to his arrest, or apparently sensitive government information..."

Turns out there was no sensitive government information. A big chunk of the chat did reveal Manning's history of cross-dressing and his gender identity crisis—he's apparently transgendered—which Lamo, himself bisexual, played on to win his trust. But other bits showed the depths to which Lamo went to extract information from Manning.

Here's Lamo telling Manning their conversation would be protected because Lamo is "a journalist and a minister":

(10:20:53 AM) bradass87: yes... questioned my gender for several years... sexual orientation was easy to figure out... but i started to come to terms with it during the first few months of my deployment
(10:21:09 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: May I ask the particulars?
(10:21:34 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: I'm bi myself, and my ex is MTF.
(10:21:34 AM) bradass87: im fairly open... but careful, so yes..
(10:22:00 AM) bradass87: im aware of your bi part
(10:22:24 AM) bradass87: uhm, trying to keep a low profile for now though, just a warning
(10:23:34 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: I'm a journalist and a minister. You can pick either, and treat this as a confession or an interview (never to be published) & enjoy a modicum of legal protection.

Later, Manning told Lamo, "im not a source for you… im talking to you as someone who needs moral and emotional fucking support." Lamo reassured Manning, " i told you, none of this is for print."

After Manning's arrest, Lamo would lie to our own John Cook, then working for Yahoo! News, telling him, "I told [Manning], 'Look-I am a journalist, and California [where Lamo lives] has a shield law… I asked him if he wanted that choice, and he did not.'"

Regardless of what you think of Manning's alleged leak, or Lamo's turning him in—and reasonable people disagree!—Lamo is objectively a scumbag for having repeatedly reassured a troubled 22-year-old that he was speaking to a journalist off the record, then turning around giving the scoop to his buddies at Wired to fulfill his well-documented love of the spotlight. And luckily for him, Wired left out all the parts that made him look bad when it went initially to press so he was able to run around lying to pump himself up as a hero who'd saved the country from a madman bent on America's destruction.

As a bonus, here's a bit from the transcript where Manning talks about how Julian Assange stuck a camera up his butt, first noticed by BoingBoing:

bradass87: assange offered me a position at wl... but im not interested right now... too much excess baggage...
(07:33:22 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: hey
(07:33:56 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: tell him i'll do opsec for 'em
(07:34:03 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: is he gay?
(07:34:11 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: *random*
(07:34:18 AM) bradass87: are you talking to the right person?
(07:34:23 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: yeah
(07:34:36 AM) bradass87: white haired crazy dude?
(07:34:38 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: continuing convo where it dropped
(07:34:43 AM) info@adrianlamo.com: yeah
(07:34:49 AM) bradass87: ah... no...
(07:34:52 AM) bradass87: very str8
(07:35:47 AM) bradass87: had a camera smuggled via rectum once... he commented that he's "definitely not gay"
(07:37:44 AM) bradass87: [long story]

[Image of Adrian Lamo via Facebook]

Original Page: http://m.gawker.com/5821227/hacker-who-turned-in-bradley-manning-is-a-bigger-scumbag-than-we-imagined

Shared from Read It Later

Elyssa Durant, Ed.M. 

United States of America 

Forgive typos! iBLAME iPhone

Posted via email from Whistleblower

Conversation Médical Records 7/11/11

attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/11/11 16:42
@matthewhughes So you are 100% sure there was no medical documents in that mail spool? =) Will you go on record saying that?
matthewhughes (@matthewhughes)
7/11/11 16:40
@attritionorg Nope. Ligatt Leaks disseminated company information, not personal medical data.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/11/11 16:40
@matthewhughes You realize your stance on this is contradictory to your stance 5 months ago on LIGATT Leaks?
matthewhughes (@matthewhughes)
7/11/11 16:34
@attritionorg OK. I concede that point. I still argue that they were fundamentally private, and should be kept so, despite the subject.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/11/11 16:33
@matthewhughes "medical document" I will agree with, but "medical records" has an entirely different connotation and bias
matthewhughes (@matthewhughes)
7/11/11 16:31
@attritionorg medical professional, with the aim of treating a problem with the patient. How are they not medical documents?
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/11/11 16:29
@matthewhughes 1. it isn't "medical records", quit saying that. 2. accomplishing anything is up to the reader, and their choice to read
matthewhughes (@matthewhughes)
7/11/11 16:25
@attritionorg Dude, you didn't need to tweet a link to his medical records. It didn't accomplish anything. It was Red Top tactics from an
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/11/11 16:24
@matthewhughes Eagerly awaiting a correction and apology on http://is.gd/eQ8YKo
matthewhughes (@matthewhughes)
7/11/11 16:22
@attritionorg Dude, you don't spread that shit. What does it accomplish? We already knew GDE was fucked up.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/11/11 16:20
@matthewhughes We did not post them online you moron. Like 1000 times, we just linked to a document made public by someone else. cc @diami03
matthewhughes (@matthewhughes)
7/11/11 15:58
@diami03 @attritionorg posted them online. Well, his psychiatric records from his time in prison.

Elyssa Durant, Ed.M. 

United States of America 

Forgive typos! iBLAME iPhone

Posted via email from Whistleblower

Conversation Lamo v Manning

attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/17/11 19:01
@schuetzdj I believe the ends justify the means, but situationally. Certainly not an absolute.
David Schuetz (@schuetzdj)
7/17/11 18:56
@attritionorg Anyway, we disagree and that's okay. But I was struck by the "ends justify the means" bit. Gives me something to contemplate.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/17/11 18:46
@schuetzdj read that line again. ".. & enjoy a modicum of legal protection." and later "i told you, none of this is for print."
David Schuetz (@schuetzdj)
7/17/11 18:26
@attritionorg I guess I don't really feel like he lied. He said "journalist & minister" once, but neither pushed the matter after that.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/17/11 18:11
@schuetzdj You call Lamo untrustworthy and convicted hacker, yet you defend his actions in lying to Manning. Odd
David Schuetz (@schuetzdj)
7/17/11 18:10
@attritionorg Manning was a dumb kid who knew what he'd done was wrong & trusted in someone demonstrably untrustworthy. Dunno. We differ. :)
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/17/11 18:04
@schuetzdj You sound like a "ends justify the means 100% of the time" kind of guy.
David Schuetz (@schuetzdj)
7/17/11 18:02
@attritionorg That may be. I let myself get drawn out too much -- my point is it's irrelevant to me.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/17/11 17:59
@schuetzdj That is the point. He is sleazy and did it for his own desire to be in the spotlight, something he has craved for years.
David Schuetz (@schuetzdj)
7/17/11 17:57
@attritionorg Could be also that he didn't know what he was in for at that stage. Or maybe he's sleazy & did it for himself. No diff to me.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/17/11 17:54
@schuetzdj Standard procedure for .. LE or a PI. It isn't standard for a journalist to do so with intent to publish despite promises.
David Schuetz (@schuetzdj)
7/17/11 17:51
@attritionorg What Lamo did may seem sneaky, or just plain wrong, but "gaining trust to get suspect to tell all" is standard procedure.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/17/11 17:47
@schuetzdj Except where he lied about being a journalist and minister, and used it to get Manning to share personal information.
David Schuetz (@schuetzdj)
7/17/11 15:48
@attritionorg Manning (may) have confessed to spying. Lamo turned him in. I don't give a damn about motivation, it was right thing to do.
attrition.org (@attritionorg)
7/17/11 15:12
Hacker Who Turned in Bradley Manning Is a Bigger Scumbag Than We Imagined - http://is.gd/6ToirO

Elyssa Durant, Ed.M. 

United States of America 

Forgive typos! iBLAME iPhone

Posted via email from Whistleblower

http://backupmy.net/welcome?t

Elyssa Durant, Ed.M. 

United States of America 

Forgive typos! iBLAME iPhone

Posted via email from Whistleblower

Harvard Law Lock Down!

JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/21/11 12:15
@BobbyCarbn @n00bznet @Baybe_Doll Anybody want to hire her dad to sure her?? http://www.durantlaw.com/ @ElyssaD

Elyssa Durant, Ed.M. 

United States of America 

Forgive typos! iBLAME iPhone

Posted via email from Whistleblower

Conversation

JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/21/11 20:31
@yo9fah Uhm I hate cats, but that is wrong #hack
George (@yo9fah)
7/21/11 20:28
@jadedsecurity Hey Boris: How to deactivate a cat‏ #hack: http://t.co/NPmQgCf
JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/21/11 20:27
@barnsniper @Abhaxas @x25princess Drugs and alcohol can make any chica hot
Jeanie (@barnsniper)
7/21/11 20:26
@Abhaxas @jadedsecurity @x25princess ! *HOT* dude can make any chica hot!
abhaxas (@Abhaxas)
7/21/11 20:21
@jadedsecurity @barnsniper @x25princess 3somes are fine as long as the 2 chicks are hot
JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/21/11 20:19
@barnsniper @Abhaxas @x25princess Oh i know... They keep trying to pull the menage thing :x
Jeanie (@barnsniper)
7/21/11 20:14
@jadedsecurity @Abhaxas & @x25princess are talking a Vegas hookup!!
JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/21/11 20:12
Bored... SOmeone amuse me ;)

Elyssa Durant, Ed.M. 

United States of America 

Forgive typos! iBLAME iPhone

Posted via email from Whistleblower

Conversation IRC

JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/22/11 11:47
@JosephKBlack @Abhaxas Awwwww... Come to webchat.. you have a room full of fans.
Joe Black ✔ Vetted (@JosephKBlack)
7/22/11 11:45
@Abhaxas I do not negotiate with Cyberterrorists. I'm like Optimus Prime meets pissed off Pikachu. I bring pain. Lots of pain. ~Joe Black
abhaxas (@Abhaxas)
7/22/11 11:19
@JosephKBlack Come to irc.freenode.net #jadedexpozure
Joe Black ✔ Vetted (@JosephKBlack)
7/22/11 11:15
@LulzSec You removed the line between military and civilian targets. Media outlets working with the LulzSec Cyberterrorists will be attacked
The Lulz Boat (@LulzSec)
7/21/11 8:18
We're currently working with certain media outlets who have been granted exclusive access to some of the News of the World emails we have.

Elyssa Durant, Ed.M. 

United States of America 

Forgive typos! iBLAME iPhone

Posted via email from Whistleblower

Target: Washington, DC

JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/22/11 20:25
@Armytra1n3d @Abhaxas @Nix0nTehDuck @x25princess WOW... #Trollin #WINNING
Armytra1n3d (@Armytra1n3d)
7/22/11 20:23
@Abhaxas @Nix0nTehDuck @jadedsecurity Well at least we all dont have to listen to @x25princess yelling at the duck again #Trollin #WINNING
abhaxas (@Abhaxas)
7/22/11 20:22
@Nix0nTehDuck @jadedsecurity now you've done pissed the duck off, great.
Ducky Nixon (@Nix0nTehDuck)
7/22/11 20:21
@jadedsecurity http://bit.ly/qnbN8D FUCK you Ruskie...Megadeath- Angry again
JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/22/11 20:17
@barnsniper @Abhaxas think he's cheating on her already.
Jeanie (@barnsniper)
7/22/11 20:17
@Abhaxas @jadedsecurity now that is wrong! lmao
abhaxas (@Abhaxas)
7/22/11 20:15
@jadedsecurity yea i need a hand-job
JadedSecurity √ (@jadedsecurity)
7/22/11 20:13
Think I'm available as of right now for first week of August. Any projects before DC?

Elyssa Durant, Ed.M. 

United States of America 

Forgive typos! iBLAME iPhone

Posted via email from Whistleblower